In the episode Keep the Home Fires Burning, Red is at a club flirting with women when Wynonna Earp shows up. To piss her off, he bites the finger off one of the ladies he was flirting with and runs away. Wynonna shoots him, not with Peacemaker, which causes chaos at the club and allows Red to escape. Later, he is seen back at the trailer park, playing poker with other Revenants and Doc. He finally arrives as Shorty's to try and steal Peacemaker. He is able to grab the gun before Wynonna, but it burns his hand and causes him to collapse. Wynonna uses the opportunity to shoot Red with Peacemaker and send him back to hell.